Home » Uncategorized » Review: The Five-Year Engagement

Review: The Five-Year Engagement

THE FIVE-YEAR ENGAGEMENT (MA 15+)

Where: General release

When: Opens Thursday

THE opening five minutes of The Five-Year Engagement goes something like this: boy and girl meet at New Year’s Eve party, fall madly in love, spend the next year wandering around San Francisco in a blissful state and get engaged.

The latest comedy by master producer Judd Apatow (The 40 Year Old Virgin, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Bridesmaids) starts where so many romantic comedies end – with good reason. This isn’t another Hollywood romance, but rather a film about what happens when careers, ambition and real life problems dilute what made a relationship special in the first place.

Apatow collaborator Jason Segel (who wrote the screenplay with Get Him to the Greek writer Nicholas Stoller) plays Tom, a San Franciscan sous chef who has it all – money, a great apartment, a promotion to head chef in the wings and a perfect partner in psychology graduate Violet (Emily Blunt). The wedding is postponed when Violet receives a terrific two-year job offer at a Michigan university. Tom, putting the relationship first, offers to move to across the country to support his fiance, to her delight.But he can’t score a chef job in his new (always snowing) city, and ends up in a ‘‘gourmet’’ sandwich bar only a step up from Subway alongside a collection of oddballs.

As his misery increases, he questions his own masculinity and worth while maintaining a front that all is fine. It comes to a head about two-thirds through as the couple realise they’re ‘‘almost perfect’’ for each other. Segel wonders whether almost perfect is worth giving up his career for. As has been the case with some of Apatow’s recent movies (such as Funny People), the running time is long. At more than two hours, it could have been trimmed by 30 minutes in the middle sequences where a depressed Segel grows a bushy beard and becomes a hunter.

But the two leads are a joy, and the extended cast works well (special mention to ‘‘our’’ Jacki Weaver). There’s an enormous amount of heart and depth in here, and anybody who has ever compromised a dream or ambition for love will find something to relate to.

Digital Editions


  • Severe thunderstorm warning issued

    Severe thunderstorm warning issued

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 253047 A severe thuderstorm warning and shelter indoors now alert has been issued for suburbs around Melbourne’s north-west. Residents…

More News

  • Measles exposure sites

    Measles exposure sites

    The Department of Health has listed six measles exposure sites in Tullamarine and one in Craigieburn since 10 February. The most recent exposure incidents occurred on Wednesday 18 February at…

  • Hume community grants awarded

    Hume community grants awarded

    The Australian Multicultural Community Centre, Hmong Australia Society New Year Festival and the Meadow Heights Turkish Senior Group’s International Women’s Day event are among community groups to receive funding as…

  • Yarrambat CFA celebrates 25 years

    Yarrambat CFA celebrates 25 years

    Yarrambat CFA has marked the 25th anniversary of its fire station with a day of celebration and the official opening of a new firefighter turnout room. The community celebrated together…

  • Kookettes into grand final

    Kookettes into grand final

    After tough going the first couple of years, Rivergum’s women’s side will play in its first North Metro Cricket Association grand final this Sunday. The Kookettes, who are playing finals…

  • Merzbow to bring noise to Newport

    Merzbow to bring noise to Newport

    For almost five decades now, Tokyo-based artist Merzbow has held an undisputed position as the iconic forefather of noise music. It’s said his work, which catapults the listener into an…

  • Renewable energy soars

    Renewable energy soars

    Energy and Resources Minister Lily D’Ambrosio has announced that Victoria has exceeded its 2025 renewable energy target. Ms D’Ambrosio said renewables accounted for 44.6 per cent of the state’s electricity…

  • Police appeal for information on the disappearance of Brendan Breen

    Police appeal for information on the disappearance of Brendan Breen

    Police are appealing for information as part of their investigation into the suspicious disappearance of Brendan Breen 14 years ago. The then 55-year-old was last seen in Melbourne on 12…

  • Festival for all abilities

    Festival for all abilities

    Ability Fest is returning to Melbourne on April 11, 2026, with a new focus on industrial venue accessibility at The Timber Yard in Port Melbourne. The event marks a shift…

  • Women’s history centre stage

    Women’s history centre stage

    A special one-off theatrical performance is coming to the Kyneton Town Hall in celebration of International Women’s Day. In 2026, the theme for International Women’s Day is #BalanceTheScales – a…

  • Fernando to leave Kangaroos

    Fernando to leave Kangaroos

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527936 Greenvale Kangaroos coach Sunny Fernando will walk away from the Victorian Premier Cricket club proud with what he has achieved. The Kangaroos announced…