Home » News » Storm asthma errors detailed

Storm asthma errors detailed

By Alesha Capone

 

A damning report shows that triple-0 operators made several errors that may have contributed to delays in getting help to some of the people who died in the 2016 thunderstorm asthma event.

The Inspector-General for Emergency Management’s report into emergency services’ response during the thunderstorm asthma tragedy states that some operators did not advise callers there were long waits for ambulances, but were required to tell people that “the ambulance is on the way”, regardless of whether paramedics had been dispatched or not.

In the case of Hoppers Crossing woman Hope Carnevali (also known as Hope Marsh), an operator correctly recorded she had a history of asthma, but this caused software to downgrade her case as a priority.

Hope, 20, died in front of her family’s house as she and her relatives waited for an ambulance which arrived 30 minutes after it was called.

The report states that triple-0 operators received an “unprecedented” 2666 calls in a 12-hour period during the thunderstorm asthma event in which eight people died.

Between 3pm on November 21, 2016 and 6am the following day, the Emergency Services Telecommunications Authority received 2666 requests for paramedics to assist with emergency and non-emergency cases, of which 962 were related to breathing problems.

The report notes the Emergency Services Telecommunications Authority has upgraded training for its operators.

“We offer our condolences to the families and friends of the people who died as a result of the unprecedented thunderstorm asthma event,” the authority said in a statement.

 

– with

The Age

Digital Editions


  • Severe thunderstorm warning issued

    Severe thunderstorm warning issued

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 253047 A severe thuderstorm warning and shelter indoors now alert has been issued for suburbs around Melbourne’s north-west. Residents…

More News

  • Measles exposure sites

    Measles exposure sites

    The Department of Health has listed six measles exposure sites in Tullamarine and one in Craigieburn since 10 February. The most recent exposure incidents occurred on Wednesday 18 February at…

  • Hume community grants awarded

    Hume community grants awarded

    The Australian Multicultural Community Centre, Hmong Australia Society New Year Festival and the Meadow Heights Turkish Senior Group’s International Women’s Day event are among community groups to receive funding as…

  • Yarrambat CFA celebrates 25 years

    Yarrambat CFA celebrates 25 years

    Yarrambat CFA has marked the 25th anniversary of its fire station with a day of celebration and the official opening of a new firefighter turnout room. The community celebrated together…

  • Kookettes into grand final

    Kookettes into grand final

    After tough going the first couple of years, Rivergum’s women’s side will play in its first North Metro Cricket Association grand final this Sunday. The Kookettes, who are playing finals…

  • Merzbow to bring noise to Newport

    Merzbow to bring noise to Newport

    For almost five decades now, Tokyo-based artist Merzbow has held an undisputed position as the iconic forefather of noise music. It’s said his work, which catapults the listener into an…

  • Renewable energy soars

    Renewable energy soars

    Energy and Resources Minister Lily D’Ambrosio has announced that Victoria has exceeded its 2025 renewable energy target. Ms D’Ambrosio said renewables accounted for 44.6 per cent of the state’s electricity…

  • Police appeal for information on the disappearance of Brendan Breen

    Police appeal for information on the disappearance of Brendan Breen

    Police are appealing for information as part of their investigation into the suspicious disappearance of Brendan Breen 14 years ago. The then 55-year-old was last seen in Melbourne on 12…

  • Festival for all abilities

    Festival for all abilities

    Ability Fest is returning to Melbourne on April 11, 2026, with a new focus on industrial venue accessibility at The Timber Yard in Port Melbourne. The event marks a shift…

  • Women’s history centre stage

    Women’s history centre stage

    A special one-off theatrical performance is coming to the Kyneton Town Hall in celebration of International Women’s Day. In 2026, the theme for International Women’s Day is #BalanceTheScales – a…

  • Fernando to leave Kangaroos

    Fernando to leave Kangaroos

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527936 Greenvale Kangaroos coach Sunny Fernando will walk away from the Victorian Premier Cricket club proud with what he has achieved. The Kangaroos announced…