Home » News » Mixed reaction to Sunbury auditors’ report

Mixed reaction to Sunbury auditors’ report

Sunbury Residents Association president and long-time split campaigner Bernie O’Farrell says people ‘’won’t stand for’’ the transition auditors’ decision to recommend that the town remain a part of Hume.

Slamming the auditors’ report, which said the planned split was “too problematic”, Mr O’Farrell accused the state government of having already made its decision before launching the year-long review.

“All the evidence to support separation was there in the reports prepared for the previous panel,” he said.

In their report, auditors Frank Vincent and John Watson said they believed the previous financial advice prepared by three consultants affirmed that a Sunbury council was unlikely to be financially sustainable in the short or long term without significant financial assistance, high rates and/or reduced services.

Mr O’Farrell maintained the case for the split was concrete.

“We don’t accept that the auditors’ conclusions are based on factual evidence,’’ he said.

Mr O’Farrell repeated claims made by Opposition Leader Matthew Guy and Western Metropolitan MP Bernie Finn that the government was bowing to pressure from unions.

“The government was very much influenced by the Australian Services Union in all this,’’ he said.

“They’d made up their minds right from day one.’’

Mr O’Farrell said pro-split supporters would keep fighting for an independent Sunbury, regardless of Local Government Minister Natalie Hutchins’ eventual decision.

“The people will not accept this. The campaign will continue even if it takes the election of a new government in three and a half years’ time.’’

Flabbergasted

Sunbury-based Hume councillor Jack Medcraft said he was flabbergasted by the government’s arrogance.

“This was an absolute charade,” he said.

“We were conned. They knew exactly what they wanted.”

Cr Medcraft repeated his concern that the auditors did not take into account the government’s plans to cap council rates and $30 million raised from the sale of land in Racecourse Road.

“We’ve been held to ransom by unions to pay for Craigieburn’s Labor domination.”

“Time to move on”

Fellow Sunbury-based councillor Ann Potter said she hoped people would move on.

“The report vindicates what I’ve been saying for 12-18 months,’’ she said.

“At the end of the day, you can make anything viable but you have to do it by increasing rates significantly or cutting services.

‘’We’ve been governing with uncertainty for too long. We want to get on with things like planning the new global learning centre.

“There’s been enough delays.’’

Hume chief executive Domenic Isola said the council held serious concerns about the process undertaken by the previous government.

“Council expressed its concerns to the former government on a number of occasions, especially in regards to the timeframes imposed, the process of asset distribution, the obligations and costs imposed on the community and the significant impact to staff,” Mr Isola said.

“We welcome the acknowledgement of these issues by the transition auditors in their report.’’

Both Mr Isola and mayor Adem Atmaca urged the government to make its final decision quickly.

Digital Editions


  • Bundoora Beats set for summer

    Bundoora Beats set for summer

    Bundoora Beats has been rescheduled to January 31, bringing together local and international musicians for a night of summer sounds. JAZZPARTY is a Melbourne-based band…

More News

  • Tim Tszyu condemns Zerafa for lame finish

    Tim Tszyu condemns Zerafa for lame finish

    Team Tszyu and livid, can-throwing fans have condemned Michael Zerafa for “cowardly” forcing officials to stop short Australian boxing’s biggest grudge match this century. Zerafa was booed out of the…

  • Start your engines, Bacchus Marsh

    Start your engines, Bacchus Marsh

    Get set for engines to roar and propellers to spin as Bacchus Marsh Wings, Wheels, and Coffee returns for 2026, promising a high-octane day where horsepower meets skypower. Taking off…

  • Awards to honour state’s sporting heroes

    Awards to honour state’s sporting heroes

    Nominations are now open for the 2025 Victorian Sport Awards (VSAs). Presented by the Victorian Government and Vicsport, the VSAs are the most prestigious night for the state’s sporting and…

  • Safety excellence to be rewarded at WorkSafe awards

    Safety excellence to be rewarded at WorkSafe awards

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 183103 Workplace safety champions and innovators from across Victoria will be celebrated at the 2025 WorkSafe Awards next month. From 95 submitted nominations, 22…

  • Grants open for grassroots multicultural groups

    Grants open for grassroots multicultural groups

    The state government has opened applications for a new $5 million grant program aimed at supporting multicultural and multifaith groups across the state. Known as the Multicultural Capacity Building Program,…

  • Concerns over AI safety

    Concerns over AI safety

    The eSafety Commissioner is sounding the alarm over the use of the generative artificial intelligence system known as Grok on the social media platform X, following concerns that the tool…

  • Clotheslined to clobber Footscray

    Clotheslined to clobber Footscray

    Inner-west punters should prepare to get well and truly cleaned-up and checked for concussion when five of Melbourne’s toughest and hardest bands take over Footscray this Australia Day weekend. Headlined…

  • Victorian bushfire appeal accepting donations

    Victorian bushfire appeal accepting donations

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 201153 Victorian’s are being urged to give generously to support communities devastated by the state’s ongoing bushfire emergency. The Victorian Emergency Relief and Recovery…

  • Air quality advice

    Air quality advice

    With bushfires burning across the state, Environment Protection Authority Victoria (EPA) is providing regular air-quality updates. EPA is monitoring air quality using its stationary and mobile monitoring stations and publishing…

  • Serving up more public transport for Australian Open

    Serving up more public transport for Australian Open

    Thousands of extra public transport services will be available for tennis fans heading to the Australian Open. Public and Active Transport Minister Gabrielle Williams announced that almost 5000 extra trams,…