Home » News » Don’t argue with Eliza

Don’t argue with Eliza

This softly spoken 16-year-old knows how to craft an argument and deliver it with panache.

St Monica’s College student Eliza Geraghty has won the Debaters Association of Victoria’s Swannie Award as ‘best debater’ in Melbourne’s northern region.

To win the award she had to have the highest average score after at least three debates against schools around the state this year.

Ms Geraghty, of Mill Park, says she hopes to use her oratory skills later in life as a social worker for the Department of Health and Human Services, working closely with children and teenagers.

To date, her favourite debate has been about whether capital punishment should be reintroduced in Australia.

It was a “secret topic”; students were told of it only about an hour before they had to debate it earlier this year. They were not allowed computers, phones or electronic equipment to help them research and formulate their ideas and opinions.

“I really enjoyed it, but it was also one of the hardest because it’s such a sensitive topic,” Ms Geraghty said.

The year 11 student said she was indebted to her parents and the school for allowing her to take debating to a competitive level.

St Monica’s College principal Brian Hanley was thrilled Ms Geraghty’s skills were being recognised outside the school.

“Eliza is a very competent public speaker and debater who relishes the challenges presented by debating,” he said.

“Her consistently high level of presentation is a credit to her.”

The Swannie awards are named after Alan Swanwick, a world-renowned Victorian debater and adjudicator.

Digital Editions


  • Multicultural health committee expanded

    Multicultural health committee expanded

    Victoria’s Multicultural Health Advisory Committee has been expanded in an effort to make the state’s health system more inclusive and increasingly diverse. Health Minister Mary-Anne…

More News

  • Jumpstarting young driving journeys

    Jumpstarting young driving journeys

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 228084 A new program will help young people from refugee backgrounds learn to drive. Minister for Roads and Road Safety Melissa Horne announced the…

  • Out and about

    Out and about

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532105 Each week Star Weekly photographers are out and about capturing events and people across the Macedon Ranges, Hume and Whittlesea.

  • Plea to save bus stops

    Plea to save bus stops

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 533386 An Epping man is calling on his neighbours and the wider community to help save the bus stops along Lyndarum Drive and Rockfield…

  • Keeping Hume cool

    Keeping Hume cool

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 336543 Hume councillor Naim Kurt has put heat on keeping community centres doors open on hot days. At the 9 February council meeting, Cr…

  • From the archives

    From the archives

    Star Weekly looks back on the pages of our predecessors. 10 years ago 8 March, 2016 A third train station, near Hawkstowe Parade, is likely to be incorporated into the…

  • Migrants helping others build new lives

    Migrants helping others build new lives

    Five migrants and former refugees who sought help to find employment after arriving in Australia are now part of a team successfully supporting other new arrivals build new lives in…

  • New look Hume ready to do

    New look Hume ready to do

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 458912 It’s been an off season of change for Hume City in the National Premier League. While Hume finished in seventh and only two…

  • Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 533209 Kalkallo sports fest Join ex-BBL cricketer Ryan Carters, and Dutch soccer player Tom Ruijs for an afternoon of free sport and games for…

  • Food funding starved

    Food funding starved

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532105 Lalor Neighbourhood House (LNH) volunteers have been left unable to feed over 90 families after the state government cut $45,000 in funding. LNH…

  • Mernda man arrested in construction crime probe

    Mernda man arrested in construction crime probe

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 A Mernda man is one of three men who were arrested during a police investigation into organised crime linked to the construction industry.…