Home » News » Don’t argue with Eliza

Don’t argue with Eliza

This softly spoken 16-year-old knows how to craft an argument and deliver it with panache.

St Monica’s College student Eliza Geraghty has won the Debaters Association of Victoria’s Swannie Award as ‘best debater’ in Melbourne’s northern region.

To win the award she had to have the highest average score after at least three debates against schools around the state this year.

Ms Geraghty, of Mill Park, says she hopes to use her oratory skills later in life as a social worker for the Department of Health and Human Services, working closely with children and teenagers.

To date, her favourite debate has been about whether capital punishment should be reintroduced in Australia.

It was a “secret topic”; students were told of it only about an hour before they had to debate it earlier this year. They were not allowed computers, phones or electronic equipment to help them research and formulate their ideas and opinions.

“I really enjoyed it, but it was also one of the hardest because it’s such a sensitive topic,” Ms Geraghty said.

The year 11 student said she was indebted to her parents and the school for allowing her to take debating to a competitive level.

St Monica’s College principal Brian Hanley was thrilled Ms Geraghty’s skills were being recognised outside the school.

“Eliza is a very competent public speaker and debater who relishes the challenges presented by debating,” he said.

“Her consistently high level of presentation is a credit to her.”

The Swannie awards are named after Alan Swanwick, a world-renowned Victorian debater and adjudicator.

Digital Editions


  • NFL women’s fixtures released

    NFL women’s fixtures released

    There will be no re-grading for the Northern Football League women’s competition this season. The league released its women’s fixtures on Monday, with 31 teams…

More News

  • Olympian to open skate park

    Olympian to open skate park

    Meet an Olympic skateboarder and enjoy live music at the Sounds of Summer skate park event in Donnybrook this Saturday 21 February. Olympian Hayley Wilson will make a special appearance…

  • Donnybrook community centre opening

    Donnybrook community centre opening

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530682 Residents are invited to mark a major milestone in Donnybrook’s history with the official opening of the murnong community centre this Saturday 21…

  • Guitar virtuoso to take centre stage

    Guitar virtuoso to take centre stage

    The tiny, yet very mighty, Melbourne Chamber Orchestra is making its way to the west later this month. The orchestra will present its new show Flexible Sky, starring Slava Grigoryan,…

  • Ambulance response times climbing

    Ambulance response times climbing

    Ambulance response times have been released for October to December 2025, with response times slightly increasing in the northern suburbs. According to Ambulance Victoria, Hume ranked third across the state…

  • Experience musical classics live

    Experience musical classics live

    Experience classic musical songs from The Phantom of the Opera to Cats live in South Morang at the premier Michael Crawford tribute show ‘Phantom’. Keith McNamara is excited to perform…

  • Community grants flow

    Community grants flow

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530187 A sports playgroup for toddlers, a STEM school holiday program, a community volleyball initiative and a Pasifika community program are among the projects…

  • Keeping Hume cool on hot days

    Keeping Hume cool on hot days

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 336543 Hume councillor Naim Kurt has put heat on keeping community centres doors open on hot days. At the 9 February council meeting, Cr…

  • Calling all artists

    Calling all artists

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 336543 Applications for the Hume Gallery annual exhibition are now open, offering emerging artists the chance to display their work. The program aims to…

  • Stars with work to do

    Stars with work to do

    Everything is on the line for the Lalor Stars in the Diamond Valley Cricket Association Money Shield in the remaining two rounds. The Stars sit second last with two rounds…

  • New look Hume ready to do

    New look Hume ready to do

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 458912 It’s been an off season of change for Hume City in the National Premier League. While Hume finished in seventh and only two…